U.S. Department of Labor finalizes new independent contractor rule; lease-purchase of a truck is no longer treated as “control”
The U.S. Department of Labor issued the final independent contractor (IC) rule on November 19. It largely follows the February proposal and is generally seen as more favorable to owner-operators who want to keep independent contractor status.
Source:FreightWaves · Original article
The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) issued a new independent contractor classification rule on November 19. Compared with the proposal from February this year, it made only minimal changes, and it will replace the rule from the Biden administration. The new rule takes effect 60 days after it is formally published in the Federal Register.
The focus of the new rule is to highlight two core factors in the “economic reality” multifactor test: the degree of control over the work, and the opportunity for profit or loss. If these two factors point to the same conclusion, that will usually be enough to determine status. Especially important for the trucking industry, the Labor Department made clear that a lease-purchase agreement that genuinely gives a driver a future opportunity to own the vehicle is a sign of independent contractor status, not evidence that the carrier controls the driver; requiring a driver to comply with laws, regulations, and safety standards also does not count as the kind of “control” that creates an employment relationship.
The American Trucking Associations (ATA) welcomed the new rule. The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA) was generally supportive, saying that while the rule does not resolve every concern, it does not create new obstacles for owner-operators to work as independent contractors, and it welcomed the Labor Department’s renewed confirmation that federal regulations do not require the installation of speed limiters. Some lawyers also cautioned that courts and states often apply their own classification standards, so the practical effect of this federal rule may be limited.
For drivers and fleets that operate under lease-on or lease-purchase arrangements: federal-level risk has eased somewhat, but states such as California still have their own stricter standards. Contracts and settlement practices should still be documented in writing according to the rules of the state involved.