Non-domiciled CDL case: a federal appeals court rules in favor of New York State
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that FMCSA’s withholding of $73 million in funding from New York State because CDL expiration dates extended beyond work-authorization dates was “arbitrary and capricious,” but it did not overturn the new non-domiciled CDL rules.
Source:Land Line · Original article
On November 13, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled that FMCSA’s withholding of $73 million in federal funding from New York State on the ground that “CDL expiration dates extended beyond the holder’s work-authorization dates” was “arbitrary and capricious.” The court found that before September 2025, federal rules did not require a CDL’s expiration date to match the work authorization. A similar case in which FMCSA withheld $160 million from California is still awaiting a decision from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit.
Analysis: this ruling targets FMCSA’s withholding of funds and does not overturn the later non-domiciled CDL rules. Fleets that hire drivers who hold work authorization should still check credential expiration dates under the current rules.