Failed English checks three times and was still dispatched: FMCSA upholds revocation of a one-truck company’s operating authority
FMCSA denied the appeal of Nevada’s Arce Trucking and upheld the revocation of its operating authority. The company’s only driver was cited three times for failing to meet English-language proficiency requirements, and enrolling the driver in English classes was not accepted as sufficient.
Source:FreightFiles · Original article
According to FreightFiles on November 17, an FMCSA deputy administrator, acting as the agency decisionmaker, denied the request by Nevada one-truck company Arce Trucking LLC to set aside the revocation and upheld the revocation of its operating authority issued in June this year. The company’s only driver, who is also a managing member, was cited three times between 2023 and 2026 for violating the English-language proficiency requirement in 49 CFR 391.11(b)(2). FMCSA said the company continued to dispatch him even though it knew of the violations, including twice after he had been placed out of service.
The company argued that it had enrolled the driver in English classes, that there had been no crashes, and that revocation was too severe. FMCSA found that enrolling in an English class does not prove the driver currently has adequate English proficiency, and that the company only promised to take the driver off the road after the revocation order was issued, so it concluded the company knowingly failed to demonstrate compliance. The company may still apply as provided to have the revocation set aside after taking corrective action, or file a petition in a federal court of appeals.
For Chinese-speaking drivers and owner-operators with their own authority, this case shows that in a one-truck company the driver and the company are one and the same. Repeated English-language citations can cost more than a ticket — they can cost the entire MC authority. After being placed out of service, the driver must not keep operating. English proficiency has to actually improve, and at roadside inspections the driver needs to be able to answer officers’ questions in English and read traffic signs.